Campbell-Ewald relies on what should be a legal non-starter: an unaccepted settlement offer. Under normal legal rules, an unaccepted offer becomes null and void. But Campbell-Ewald uses Gomez’s refusal to settle to argue that his case, along with the claims of the entire putative class, should be kicked out of court. In this clip, listen as Justices Sotomayor, Ginsburg, and Kagan press Garre to show the Court any relevant, legal precedent to support the company’s unorthodox view.